21 Desserts You Can Make With Leftover Halloween Candy
Don’t let that mountain of leftover Halloween candy go to waste! Whether you’re dealing with fun-size chocolate bars, bags of candy corn, or those forgotten pieces at the bottom of the trick-or-treat bowl, these creative dessert ideas will turn your candy stash into delicious homemade treats. From quick no-bake options to impressive layered desserts, there’s something here for every skill level and sweet tooth.
1. Candy Bar Brownies
These fudgy brownies get a serious upgrade when you chop up leftover candy bars and fold them right into the batter. The candy pieces create pockets of different textures and flavors throughout each bite. You can use any combination of chocolate bars you have on hand – Snickers, Twix, and Milky Way work especially well. They’re incredibly easy to make using your favorite brownie mix, and the candy adds such a fun surprise element that everyone will be asking for the recipe.
Get the recipe here.
2. Halloween Candy Bark
This is probably the easiest way to use up a variety of leftover candies, and it looks absolutely stunning when finished. Simply melt chocolate, spread it on a lined baking sheet, then press your candy pieces on top before it sets. The beauty is in the colorful chaos – mix different textures like crunchy candy corn with chewy gummies and chocolate pieces. It breaks into rustic, beautiful pieces that make great gifts or party treats, and you can customize it with whatever candy you have.
Get the recipe here.
3. Leftover Candy Cookies
Transform basic sugar cookie dough into something extraordinary by mixing in chopped pieces of your Halloween haul. The cookies bake up soft and chewy with bursts of candy flavors in every bite. Different candies will behave differently in the oven – some will melt slightly while others hold their shape, creating an interesting variety of textures. These are perfect for using up those random single pieces of candy that kids don’t want, and they freeze beautifully for later.
Get the recipe here.
4. Candy-Stuffed Cupcakes
Take ordinary cupcakes to the next level by hiding candy surprises inside before baking. Simply fill your cupcake liners halfway with batter, add a few pieces of candy, then top with more batter. As they bake, some candy will melt into gooey pockets while others stay intact for delightful textural contrast. Top with your favorite frosting and maybe even more candy pieces for decoration. Kids absolutely love the surprise element when they bite into these treats.
Get the recipe here.
5. Snickers Cheesecake
This rich, decadent cheesecake captures all the flavors of the beloved candy bar in dessert form. The creamy filling is studded with chopped Snickers pieces, while the crust can be made from crushed chocolate cookies mixed with more candy bits. Each slice delivers that perfect combination of chocolate, caramel, peanuts, and smooth cheesecake. It does require some time to set properly, but the hands-on prep is surprisingly simple, and the impressive results make it worth the wait.
Get the recipe here.
6. Rice Krispie Treats
Classic Rice Krispie Treats are the ultimate nostalgic dessert that takes just minutes to make. This simple recipe combines crispy rice cereal with melted marshmallows and butter to create irresistibly chewy, gooey squares. Perfect for bake sales, lunchboxes, or satisfying a sweet craving, these treats require no baking and use just three basic ingredients. The result is a beloved childhood favorite that’s crispy, sweet, and utterly addictive.
Get the recipe here.
7. Candy Corn Fudge
This festive fudge celebrates the polarizing Halloween candy in a whole new way. The creamy white chocolate base is swirled with orange and yellow colors to mimic candy corn’s iconic look, while actual candy corn pieces add pops of vanilla sweetness throughout. It’s surprisingly easy to make using the microwave method, and it sets up beautifully in just a few hours. Even people who claim to hate candy corn often find themselves loving this smooth, creamy version of the classic treat.
Get the recipe here.
8. Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie
This no-bake pie is a peanut butter lover’s dream come true, loaded with chopped Reese’s cups throughout the creamy filling. The combination of peanut butter mousse and chocolate candy pieces creates the perfect balance of flavors and textures. It sits on a chocolate cookie crust and can be ready to serve in just a few hours of chilling time. The best part is how impressive it looks despite being incredibly simple to assemble – no baking skills required whatsoever.
Get the recipe here.
9. Halloween Candy Trail Mix Bars
These chewy bars are like a grown-up version of trail mix, combining oats, nuts, and chopped Halloween candy in a sweet, satisfying treat. The base holds together beautifully thanks to a simple mixture of honey and butter, while the candy adds pops of chocolate, caramel, and fruity flavors throughout. They’re perfect for lunch boxes or afternoon snacks, and you can customize them with whatever candy combination you prefer. They also travel really well and keep for days at room temperature.
Get the recipe here.
10. Twix Caramel Apple Dip
This warm, gooey dip transforms cream cheese and caramel into an irresistible treat studded with chopped Twix bars. The combination of tart apples with sweet, crunchy candy pieces and creamy dip is absolutely addictive. It’s perfect for parties since it stays warm in a slow cooker or can be easily reheated. The prep time is minimal, but the wow factor is huge – guests always ask for the recipe. Serve it with sliced apples, and watch it disappear within minutes.
Get the recipe here.
11. M&M Sugar Cookie Bars
These bars give you all the satisfaction of sugar cookies without the hassle of rolling and cutting individual pieces. The soft, chewy base is loaded with colorful M&Ms that add both crunch and bursts of chocolate flavor. They bake up in one pan and can be cut into perfect squares once cooled. The colorful candies make them especially appealing to kids, and they’re sturdy enough for packed lunches or bake sales. Plus, they taste even better the next day as the flavors meld together.
Get the recipe here.
12. Homemade Ice Cream Sundae
Create the ultimate dessert experience by building your own ice cream sundae from scratch. Start with creamy homemade vanilla ice cream as your base, then let creativity take over with an array of toppings. Drizzle warm chocolate or caramel sauce, add fresh berries, chopped nuts, whipped cream, and a maraschino cherry on top.
Mix textures with crushed cookies, candy pieces, or toasted coconut. This customizable treat turns dessert into an interactive experience that’s perfect for family gatherings or special occasions.
Get the recipe here.
13. Halloween Candy Trifle
Layer upon layer of deliciousness makes this trifle a real showstopper dessert that’s surprisingly easy to assemble. Alternate layers of cake, pudding, whipped cream, and chopped candy pieces in a clear glass bowl for maximum visual impact.
The beauty is that you can use any cake – store-bought pound cake works perfectly – and any combination of candies you have on hand. It needs to chill for a few hours to let the flavors meld, but the actual assembly takes just minutes.
Get the recipe here.
14. Butterfinger Poke Cake
This moist, flavorful cake gets its name from the holes you poke all over it before pouring in a sweet mixture that soaks into every bite. Chopped Butterfinger bars mixed into the topping add incredible crunch and peanut butter flavor that complements the tender cake perfectly.
It’s an impressive-looking dessert that’s actually quite simple to make, and it serves a crowd beautifully. The combination of textures – soft cake with crunchy candy – makes each bite interesting and satisfying.
Get the recipe here.
15. Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies
Indulgent stuffed chocolate chip cookies take the classic treat to the next level. These oversized cookies feature a gooey center filled with extra chocolate chips, Nutella, or cookie dough, wrapped in traditional chocolate chip cookie dough. The result is a warm, melty surprise in every bite.
Perfect for special occasions or when you want to impress guests, these cookies deliver an extra dose of comfort and sweetness that transforms an ordinary cookie into an extraordinary dessert experience.
Get the recipe here.
16. Halloween Candy Puppy Chow
This addictive snack coating turns Chex cereal into candy-coated clusters that are impossible to stop eating. The traditional peanut butter and chocolate coating gets mixed with chopped Halloween candy pieces for extra flavor and crunch.
It comes together in just minutes and makes a huge batch that’s perfect for parties or gift-giving. The combination of sweet, salty, and crunchy elements hits all the right notes, and you can customize it with whatever candy you need to use up.
Get the recipe here.
17. Candy Corn White Chocolate Blondies
These decadent blondies combine the rich sweetness of white chocolate with the nostalgic flavors of Halloween’s most iconic candy. Fudgy and chewy with a tender crumb, each square is studded with melted white chocolate chips and colorful candy corn pieces that add delightful pops of vanilla, honey, and marshmallow flavor.
The candy corn softens slightly during baking, creating pockets of concentrated sweetness throughout the golden bars. Perfect for fall gatherings, these festive treats capture autumn’s playful spirit in every bite.
Get the recipe here.
18. Halloween Candy Crack Bars
These bars live up to their name – they’re absolutely addictive with a perfect balance of sweet, salty, and crunchy elements. A buttery shortbread base gets topped with caramel and chopped Halloween candy, then finished with a layer of chocolate. They’re rich, decadent, and cut into perfect squares that are impossible to resist. The combination of textures and flavors makes them incredibly satisfying, and they’re sturdy enough for gifting or potluck contributions.
Get the recipe here.
19. Leftover Candy Muddy Buddies
This twist on the classic Chex mix recipe incorporates chopped Halloween candy for extra sweetness and texture variety. The cereal gets coated in the traditional chocolate and peanut butter mixture, then tossed with powdered sugar and candy pieces. It’s incredibly easy to make and results in an addictive snack that disappears quickly. The different candy pieces add pops of color and flavor that make this version much more exciting than the original, and it’s perfect for parties or movie nights.
Get the recipe here.